EB-1 Alien of Extraordinary Ability: Does the Quality of Journals I Publish in Matter?

EB-1 Journal QualityIn order to meet the requirements for the EB-1 alien of extraordinary ability category, the EB-1 beneficiary must document that she or he meets certain regulatory requirements. One way to meet this requirement is to show that you have received a major international award such as the Nobel Prize. The second way is much more common — USCIS lists ten requirements that you could meet to show that you have risen to the top of your field. You must meet at least three out of ten and provide evidence to support extraordinary ability in your field.

However, it is not sufficient to merely document that you meet three of the ten requirements. According to Kazarian v. USCIS (2010), the USCIS examiner will not only make sure the petitioner meets at least of the criteria, but will also conduct a "final merits analysis" to determine if the beneficiary is at the top of his/her field and has demonstrated "sustained national or international acclaim." That means that the USCIS officer will evaluate the quality of the evidence submitted, and should consider all the evidence together to determine if the beneficiary meets those standards.

Therefore, the selection and presentation of evidence is tremendously important for an EB-1 case. If a potential beneficiary has authored numerous articles published in journals in his field, for example, that is not necessarily sufficient to meet the requirement of "authored scholarly articles in professional journals or other major media" (one of the 10 criteria). If those articles were published in journals with low impact factors, it is possible the examining officer would determine either that the criterion is not met, or that it doesn't meet the EB-1 standards. Likewise, if the articles are published in respectable journals, but have few or no citations, it is unlikely that the evidence would be helpful to the case, and in fact may even negatively impact the officer's view of the beneficiary's contributions. On the other hand, it is possible that a beneficiary has published at about an average rate as compared to others in her field, but she has published in a series of journals with some of the highest impact factors in the field, and her articles have also been cited numerous times, well above the average in the field. This would be much stronger evidence than more publications with lesser citations and in lesser journals.

The same analysis applies to the other criteria as well. For example, for the criteria of reviewing the work of others, if the beneficiary reviewed dissertations of PhD students studying at his own university, this would be weaker evidence, and would not likely meet the EB-1 requirements. On the other hand, if the beneficiary had reviewed several journal articles for journals with high impact factors in the field, this would likely be viewed in a positive light, combined with the beneficiary's other evidence.

High Quality Journal Publications Are Only One Type of Proof

The bottom line: quality counts, sometimes even more than quantity! That being said, there are other ways to establish your extraordinary ability — remember there are 10 criteria to chose from. An experienced immigration attorney can help you evaluate, select, prepare and present the best evidence possible for your EB-1 petition.

If you or someone you know is thinking about filing an EB-1 green card, contact our Richmond, Virginia immigration law firm today at (804) 396-3412 or fill out our online form. Our experienced immigration attorneys can help you prepare your case and stay on top of filing deadlines.

Recent blog posts

Great news for those applying for naturalization to become a US citizen! USCIS will now continue to use the 2008 version of the civics test. In the last days of the Trump administration, USCIS announced that they would use a longer and harder version… Read More
By Nikita Hernandez, Sumner Immigration Law Paralegal It’s official! You’ve become Mr. or Mrs. and want to take on your spouse’s name while getting your US permanent residence situated, but when is the best time to do that? APPLYING FOR A NAME… Read More
One of the most common questions that we receive from our clients is about case processing time. The USCIS and DOL estimated case processing times are available online, but that source can be frustrating as they sometimes give a wide range of timefra… Read More

Read More Blog Posts

“I want to thank you for doing such a great job representing me. I’m so glad we got positive results, but even before getting results, I was confident that we’ve done 100% due diligence with our RFE response. Though the questions from USCIS were i… Read More"
– Immigration Client
“I have been thru various immigration processes with several attorneys and finally got under the valuable umbrella of Emily, she represented my H1 transfer, 7th year H1 extension, Perm Process & I-140. Through all these process she was informative… Read More"
– Kumar S.

More Client Reviews